12 August 2008

olympic "sports"


for the most part i get the olympics, i really do. as a former athlete i understand competitive drive and predatory instinct (which has matured into a "grazing" instinct), and i can understand the appeal of having a single, sci-fi-comic-con type of event to celebrate athletics and competition. and really, do you even need a reason to get a bunch of young boys together in a closed stadium, strip them down, rub them in olive oil and make them run and jump and wrestle? indeed...

and there are some sports that make perfect sense: running, for instance. the need for two people to challenge each other by running from here to there is primal and probably as old as humanity itself
frank: "grog, last one to tree is a triceratops"
grog: "no fair! i've got a wife over my shoulder!"
and diving, i understand diving. i'm generally not a fan of "sports" that are judged on aesthetic value, but diving has a lot of redeeming qualities (notwithstanding the fact that divers seem to be a bit pudgier than other athletes). cycling? steeplechase? canoeing? judo? tennis? wrestling? all of these sports make sense to me.

but there are a lot of sports that i do not get. i don't understand why they are considered sports, why people want to compete in them, and why they should be inflicted upon us, the faithful olympic viewing public.
full disclosure: i am not a member of the olympic viewing public. i only watched the men's cycling road race because i actually knew someone competing (*brilliant* result, btw, for canada), and i watch some swimming because i used to swim, and i watch women's beach volleyball because of... uh, the drama and feats of athleticism...)
and i will not be convinced by the argument that something is a sport just because it requires physical effort; sometimes i break into a sweat re-tying my shoelaces, or get out-of-breath while lugging groceries up to my apartment, but i'm not arguing that *those* should be olympic activities...

so, in no particular order:
  • table tennis? really? this is a sport? a wee plastic ball that weighs as much as a hummingbird egg, a paddle from max mosley's dungeon, and a tiny little net on a folding table from somebody's basement?
  • bmx. i rode a bmx, and it is cool, but a competitive sport? pierced and tatt'ed ne'er-do-wells who can't afford belts to hold their pants up, who train by riding urban streets in search of grandmothers to purse-snatch... yeah, okay, so bmx can stay.
  • trampoline. lol. seriously.
  • synchronized swimming. this is a sport so ridiculous i can't even comment on it. it angers me. and i even *competed* it it myself! (long story, not worth the time)
  • badminton. like table tennis, but using wicker carpet beaters; i don't mind if consenting adults play badminton in the bedroom, but not the olympics...

so i propose that every olympic sport should go through a sanity check before it can be approved. the check might be something like this: put two guys together in a bar, each with a beer in their hand, and then get them to challenge each other using the sport in question. if they do not laugh, cry, blush, or get trampled by their fellow patrons, then the sport passes:
  • "dude, i bet i can lift more beer kegs over my head than you". weightlifting, check.
  • "hey hombre, you can't walk nearly as fast as i can." walking, fail.
  • "yo, bro, i bet i can throw this pointy spear/cannon ball/frisbee farther than you". javelin/shotput/discus, check/check/check.
  • "do you think i could cross this bar in just a hop, skip, and a jump? why are you hitting me?". triple jump, fail.
  • "grog, last one to tree is a triceratops". running, check.
  • "frank, i bet i can lift my legs out of the water higher than you can, while dancing to music. oh, and you have to put your hair in a bun and wear this noseclip". *biff* *boom* *kapow!*, the barroom brawl ensues.
i know there's more in here, but beach volleyball has started, and brazil is playing next...

4 comments:

Anonymous said...

Great blog entry DMG. Your criteria and proposed methodology for sport worthiness assessment are both spot on.

Ideas I propose based on riffing on your framework if I might:

Competitive dwarf tossing I think fulfills all the rated requirements you outline and is obviously a fun and healthy pursuit for the whole family don't you think? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dwarf_tossing

Standing Long Jump I again think fulfills the 'ur' requirements of your framework. Okay, discontinued from Olympics in 1912, but still very popular in Norway where the annual championships in Stange continue to this day. Incidentally the event is a must-see - and don't miss the putrified herring sandwiches at Stange - you'll be back every year. Per your Neanderthal criteria: 'Grog, I jump farther than you Grog. Grog no jump like me. Me jump so far!' I think this substantiates my proposition that standing long jump is an 'ur' sport. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standing_long_jump

BTW: I am not kidding - standing long jump is still, and quite oddly , in the elementary school physEd requirements in Ontario school curriculum.

Wife carrying - or as the Estonians call it 'naisekandmine' is just so _obviously a sport that would fulfill every aspect of your criteria of assessment! Admittedly it's kind of Freudian and some people have trouble retaining life partners so it's a tad exclusionary, but still... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wife_carrying . How did you miss this DMG?

That bog snorkelling is a no-brainer candidate for your list is friggin obvious yet you didn't mention it! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bog_snorkeling

There is a western Australian past time that involves two team of six men all equipped with sledge hammers. Each team is given an upright piano. In front of each team is a steel wall with a six inch diameter hole in it. First team to get that team's entire piano through the six in hole wins. Recordings of these events are available in MP3 format and put John Cage to shame IMHO. I propose this as a 'demonstration' sport at least (with the whole cultural/musical/post-modernist thing eh?)

Lastly, let me make a case for the Afghan sport of 'Buzhashi' (sometimes also Kok-boru or Ulak Tartysh) - or as we more commonly know it in the English-speaking west,'goat grabbing'. Hard to imagine a better candidate Olympic (summer) sport IMHO. As you know the game is played on a field approx 10x the size of a football pitch and involves teams of armed horse riders who could grab a headless goat or calf carcass from the ground while riding a horse at full gallop, the goal being to get the headless carcass clear of the other players and pitch it across a goal line or into a target circle or vat. Best part: There are _NO RULES http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Buzkashi

I only played Buzkashi for two years or so in the OPS house league in 92-94 (until the unfortunate death of Tim F. and that nice older lady Francis from Procurement). Besides the Ministry of Intergovernmental Affairs' Team didn't have a large pool of players to choose from and I always seemed to get the goat decapitation job....

Who was it who said 'I used to love playing water polo until my horse drowned?'

Regards, as ever, b

dutch me gently, please said...

dear anonymous,

thank you for your reply. sadly, i fear that i must consider deleting your text due to its gross insensitivities. we are no longer in the barbaric 20th century, and are now sufficiently enlightened that the sport is properly called "the tossing of the little people"...

i also take issue with your proposal regarding the standing long jump. if grog and frank were running through the forest with nasty dinosaurs (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rlnXc2mqaKY) chasing them down, would they come to a stop at the edge of a canyon, curl their toes over the edge, swing their arms a couple of times and *then* jump? i don't think so - they would jump while still at full trot...

and wife-carrying, like re-tying my shoes or carrying the groceries, is too much of an every-day activity to warrant inclusion...

but bog-snorkelling is brilliant! how macho is swimming through mud?!? totally! i can't believe i forgot that!!!

piano key-holing also sounds fantastic, but only if we could come up with a way of standardising the size of the hammers. and the pianos.

buzkashi sounds a little, um, well, cruel. tasty, but cruel. i'm open to suggestions on ways to make it a bit more civilized. besides, now that i am not allowed to eat dairy from cows, i need to protect the goats who keep my cheese-fetish satiated...

finally, upon further reflection, it was a great oversight for us to have omitted the most physically demanding sport of all: gurning!!! http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gurning”

best regards,

dutchmegently, please.

Schmutzie said...

You are being featured on Five Star Friday:
http://www.fivestarfriday.com/2008/08/five-star-friday-edition-19.html

Anonymous said...

Just wanted to add my 2 cents,
or .00001 Euros.

I think DMG and the first ANON ("b") have got the right idea. There must be clearly other ways to evaluate which sports get into the Olympics and there must be other sports worthy of consideration.

A few that come to mind that might meet the "bar test" if not the "drug test" would be frisbie golf ( a variation might be discus golf), Jai Alai, greased pig catching, buffalo chip tossing (similar to midget tossing but without all the polictically incorrect issues, wiffle ball, avoiding homeless crazy people (sorry this would only apply to Yonge and College in TO, elephant soccer (played in India I believe) snake charming, paint ball, don't forget the American Gladiators events and last but not least swamp buggy racing.

However, before we add more to the ever lengthening list of "sports" to be considered, allow me to add just a few more that need to be excluded. Hammer throw!?? I think someone could get seriously injured at either end of that process. I appreciate this was probably a big deal in more historic times but hey, let's get over it and move on. Besides I tried one of those things to bang in a nail. Didn't work worth a crap and nearly took my hand off.

At the risk of alienating my European colleagues, what's up with field hockey. Let's get real! If it ain't on ice it ain't hockey.! 'nuff said. Should be a winter sport anyway.

Equestrian Events.... hmm! Only in a rodeo or at the Calgary Stampede.


Fencing... too sissy. Let's have cutlass fighting... without all the padding (Yo! Jack... Jack Sparrow)and while we're at it what about pistol dueling... good old fashioned sport. Unfortunately there would be only one medal awarded.... GOLD!


And there is handball, silly walk racing.... Hmm! John Cleese would be proud.

Hopefully they have already dropped that gymnastics event (or so called) where they had the long piece of cloth tied to a stick and twirled it through the air while dancing on the mats. If that is still around let's bring in cheer leading with pom-poms.... much more interesting "sport".

Perhaps a more interesting take would be to bring back some of the old jugglers and "balancers of things" from the Ed Sullivan days.... now they were good.

So in closing let me add the sage words of a famous ball player, Yogi Berra.... "if you don't know where you are going you will end up some place else".

I had therefore better get going! Cheers! (gh) aka Zaphod Beeblebrox